Eye on Comics

Comics criticism and commentary from Don MacPherson

Archive for September, 2006

Quick Critiques – Sept. 30, 2006

Posted by Don MacPherson on 30th September 2006

Amazing Spider-Man #535 (Marvel Comics)
by J. Michael Straczynski, Ron Garney & Bill Reinhold

In the wake of Marvel’s announced delay of numerous titles and the developments in Civil War #4, readers have loudly proclaimed how disappointed they are in the crossover event. I don’t blame them, and my voice chimed in with that chorus for certain verses. But there is value in the core premise that’s at the heart of Civil War, and select crossover tie-in issues show that. This is one of them. Straczynski handles the ethical and personal conflicts of the event far more convincingly here, so much so that I feel it’s a shame he didn’t have a more direct hand in the core crossover title itself. The new conflict between Spidey and Iron Man works incredibly well, and the scene between Peter and Reed makes the latter’s participation in the registration movement a bit easier to accept. Garney’s incorporates an energetic, traditional super-hero genre look with a slightly edgy, tense atmosphere that’s in keeping with the script. There’s nothing wrong with these ideas; it’s in the execution that they succeed or fall apart. 8/10 Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Quick Critiques | 17 Comments »

Hush Little Baby, Don’t You Cry…

Posted by Don MacPherson on 29th September 2006

Astonishing X-Men #17
Writer: Joss Whedon
Artist/Cover artist: John Cassaday
Colors: Laura Martin
Letters: Chris Eliopoulos
Editor: Mike Marts
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Price: $2.99 US/$3.75 CAN

Everyone daydreams about his or her future. About the perfect job, the perfect mate, the perfect life. For some, it involves riches and wild times that never end. A few years ago, that’s what it meant to me. Now, I’m in a great relationship, and I was honestly surprised when her dreams of a small family and a comfortable home became my own. At first, I wanted it because she did, and I wanted to make her dream come true. But slowly but surely, I started thumbing through the paper’s real-estate insert of my own accord. I started taking notice of babies and of the possibilities that lay ahead. The opening scene in this comic book delves into such a promise, into such a dream, and it explores the pain of someone using that dream against you. Whedon offers up an exciting, well-balanced script full of emotion and drama with a touch of humor, all brought to life in convincing detail by artist John Cassaday. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Marvel | 6 Comments »

The Answers Are Blowin’ in the Wind

Posted by Don MacPherson on 28th September 2006

Justice League of America v.2 #2
“The Tornado’s Path, Chapter Two: Tornado-Red/Tornado-Blue”
Writer: Brad Meltzer
Pencils: Ed Benes
Inks: Sandra Hope
Colors: Alex Sinclair
Letters: Rob Leigh
Cover artists: Michael Turner/Phil Jimenez & Andy Lanning
Publisher: DC Comics
Price: $2.99 US/$4 CAN

There are a couple of plot developments in this issue that don’t quite make sense to me. The disconnect between the big three iconic heroes and the rest of the case is frustrating, for example, and Black Lightning doesn’t seem to act in the most intuitive manner either. Still, there’s something fun and engrossing about this issue, and it’s the air of mystery Meltzer brings to the book. There’s a real sense of buildup here and a hint of an epic, larger-than-life threat that only a team of god-like heroes can combat. Meltzer’s script also adds credibility to the genre by creating a convincing super-criminal underworld that has an air of logic to it but also pays homage to the many stories that have come before this one. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - DC | 1 Comment »

Cloning Around

Posted by Don MacPherson on 28th September 2006

Ultimate Spider-Man #100
“Clone Saga, Part 4″
Writer: Brian Michael Bendis
Pencils/Cover artist: Mark Bagley
Inks: John Dell & Drew Hennessy
Colors: Justin Ponsor
Letters: Virtual Calligraphy
Editor: Ralph Macchio
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Price: $3.99 US/$4.75 CAN

One hundred issues in six years, all by the same creative team. It’s actually quite an accomplishment on several levels, especially in the context of the comic-book industry today. Bendis and Bagley took the title character back to his roots as a regular teenage kid who finds himself in way over his head on a regular basis and added to it more modern sensibilities. Bendis built a solid foundation for the series by keeping Peter Parker’s feet planted firmly on the ground, so it’s unfortunate that this milestone gets away from that strength. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Marvel | 15 Comments »

Annotations – Justice League of America #2

Posted by Don MacPherson on 27th September 2006

Novelist and comics writer Brad Meltzer is clearly a fan of old-school DC comics, especially from the 1970s and ’80s. It shows through in his writing in the form of a myriad of characters and continuity references, ranging from the easily recognizable to the obscure. Last month, I wrote and published annotations of Meltzer’s first issue of the new Justice League of America series back on my previous site, The Fourth Rail. Those notes were pretty well received (and thanks to those who offered feedback). After perusing the pages of the second issue, it struck me that another set of annotations might be welcomed, as some lesser known references are to be found in this second chapter of “The Tornado’s Path.” So, without ado, let’s proceed, but beware, there are spoilers ahead… Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Features | 12 Comments »

Quick Critiques – Sept. 26, 2006

Posted by Don MacPherson on 26th September 2006

Checkmate #6 (DC Comics)
by Greg Rucka, Nunzio Defilippis, Christina Weir, Cliff Richards & Dan Green

DC revives the Suicide Squad yet again, and it makes sense of the concept to arise in this series, given that Amanda Waller is a significant player. This story will be thoroughly satisfying for fans of the John Ostrander-penned series of the 1980s. The concept is a solid one, and the writers explore it within the context of the DC Universe at the moment: namely, one in which just about every super-villain is organized under the umbrella of the Society. It’s a suspense-filled, entertaining script… for those of us who are up on all of the details. Those who haven’t read the first Suicide Squad series or Villains United will no doubt feel as though they were left out of the loop. Furthermore, DC can’t seem to decide what it wants to do in regard to the status of the Tattooed Man; I’m not sure, but now there are at least two of them running around, if not three, all with the same powers. Cliff Richards’s fill-in art starts off strong, bringing an appropriately gritty, convincing quality into play. The linework gets rougher as the issue progresses, as though the artists were rushed toward the end. Of course, a side effect of that lesser level of detail and definition later on is that the art looks a bit like that of Luke McDonnell, the first regular penciller on the original Suicide Squad series. 6/10 Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Quick Critiques | 7 Comments »

An All-Ages Book That’s ‘Arrrrr’-Rated

Posted by Don MacPherson on 25th September 2006

Polly and the Pirates trade paperback
Writer/Artist/Cover artist: Ted Naifeh
Editors: James Lucas Jones & Joe Nozemack
Publisher: Oni Press
Price: $11.95 US

One might assume that creator Ted Naifeh was just jumping on the Pirates of the Caribbean bandwagon when he came up with this all-ages read about adventure on the high seas. While the book boasts the same sense of fun and adventure as the movie franchise, there’s also an innocence and purity to these characters that sets it apart. Polly and the Pirates simply wreaks of entertainment and charm. There’s not a single character — from the title character herself to the lowliest villainous henchman — that doesn’t boast a strong degree of appeal. Naifeh’s designs for the Victorian Neverland in which the story is set are stunning and wondrous, and the wide-eyed characters are a delight to the eyes as well. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Oni Press | 11 Comments »

Sex Cells

Posted by Don MacPherson on 25th September 2006

How to Make Money Like a Porn Star original graphic novel
Writer: Neil Strauss
Artist: Bernard Chang
Publisher: HarperCollins/Regan Books
Price: $19.95 US/$25.95 CAN

I hadn’t heard of Neil Strauss and Bernard Chang’s previous collaboration, How to Make Love Like a Porn Star (a book listed as being written by porn icon Jenna Jameson), but it seems this is the spiritual sequel to that book. In his introduction, Strauss makes it clear that this cynical, dark, violent satire arose from his contact with porn stars in preparation for the previous book. In his observations in the introduction, it’s clear that there’s a strong, character-driven drama to be told about the damaged people who populate the adult film industry. But that’s not what this book is about. Strauss exaggerates the victimization and circumstances to the point of disbelief, and any degree of effective satire is lost in the lack of focus and flow in the storytelling. The good news is that artist Bernard Chang demonstrates some real growth and development in his art, and I’d love to see his work on higher-profile and more thoughtful comics in the future. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Miscellaneous | Comments Off

Feat of Clay (and Kavalier)

Posted by Don MacPherson on 24th September 2006

The Escapists #s 1 & 2
Writer: Brian K. Vaughan
Artists: Philip Bond, Eduardo Barreto, Steve Rolston & Jason Alexander
Colors: Dave Stewart, Paul Hornschemeier & Matt Hollingsworth
Letters: Tom Orzechowski
Cover artists: Frank Miller & James Jean
Editor: Diana Schutz
Publisher: Dark Horse Comics
Price: $1 US (#1) & $2.99 US (#2)

I haven’t read The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay, Michael Chabon’s Pulitzer-Prize winning novel about two comics creators in the Golden Age of the industry. I sampled some of the stories from Dark Horse’s Escapist anthology, featuring the adventures of the Kavalier/Clay-“created” super-hero. It was diverting, but I found creators were essentially using the character to tell new “classic” stories in the vein of other characters, such as the Spirit and the Batman. I lost interest, as the book really didn’t stand out from the crowd. I suppose that’s why this new series, The Escapists, failed to grab my attention at first. Buzz about this series is growing, and justifiably so. Y: The Last Man and Runaways creator Brian K. Vaughan has done it again, crafting another must-read comic that demonstrates the writer’s keen appreciation of human behavior. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Dark Horse | 5 Comments »

Quick Critiques – Sept. 21, 2006

Posted by Don MacPherson on 21st September 2006

Civil War #4 (Marvel Comics)
by Mark Millar, Steve McNiven & Dexter Vines

Remember Avengers #500-503?  The “Disassembled” story arc? And Identity Crisis? This issue of Civil War reminds me of those stories quite a bit, mainly because the plot is mired in the unnecessary and difficult-to-accept deaths of several characters, more for impact than anything else. This issue has already irked a number of readers, though I would imagine the ill will that its lateness fostered might have something to do with it. After reading this issue, I was a bit torn. There were elements I just didn’t buy — such as Reed’s and Tony’s willingness to accept that former allies would have to die for their cause, not to mention their new “recruits,” as revealed on the final page. But other elements in the book are strong. We finally get to see the long-promised rift in the Fantastic Four, and it’s a subplot in which the character of the Invisible Woman really shines. And McNiven’s art is, as always, powerfully detailed and effective in conveying the dire atmosphere of the story. In the end, though, the plot is quickly losing credibility despite some interesting character bits. 5/10  Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Quick Critiques | 24 Comments »

A British Invasion

Posted by Don MacPherson on 21st September 2006

Union Jack v.2 #1
“Enemies of the Crown”
Writer: Christos N. Gage
Pencils/Cover artist: Mike Perkins
Inks: Andrew Hennessy
Colors: Laura Villari
Letters: Virtual Calligraphy
Editor: Andy Schmidt
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Price: $2.99 US/$3.75 CAN

I stopped following Ed Brubaker’s Captain America run a couple of issues ago. Though I enjoyed the Winter Soldier subplot, the whole Invaders story arc struck me as just a rehash of past stories (as did the Cosmic Cube’s incorporation into the plot earlier in the series). As a result, my interest in this new Union Jack limited series was somewhat minimal, but when I heard about writer Christos Gage’s use of Israeli and Arab heroes in the story, my interest was piqued. I’m pleased I picked this book up. Politics are front and centre in this story, not the title character’s history. Gage has developed a plot that allows for the color and fun of super-hero action with the tension and intellect of a political thriller. I was also pleased to find that one needn’t have read recent issues of Cap (or any past Invaders comics) to follow this story. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Marvel | 6 Comments »

Eye on Comics – An Introduction

Posted by Don MacPherson on 19th September 2006

Welcome to Eye on Comics, my latest foray into online commentary about comics.  I’m Don MacPherson, perhaps best known as half of the reviewing team responsible for The Fourth Rail, my previous comics review website with partner Randy Lander.

Randy and I decided (independently of one another, actually) last month we were both tired of The Fourth Rail format and wanted to start fresh.  Randy and some friends down in Austin, Texas, had an idea for a new site that evolved into the already-popular ComicPants.com.  I also wanted to rebrand and start fresh, but I was looking to go in a different direction than Randy. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Announcements | 18 Comments »

Criminal Tendencies

Posted by Don MacPherson on 19th September 2006

Criminal #1
“Coward, Part One of Five”
Writer: Ed Brubaker
Artist/Cover artist: Sean Phillips
Colors: Val Staples
Publisher: Marvel Comics/Icon imprint
Price: $2.99 US/$3.75 CAN

Those who have read Ed Brubaker’s foray into the espionage genre (by way of super-heroes and villains, in Sleeper) won’t be surprised at how well he pulls off a journey through an urban underworld in his latest project, Criminal.  This is classic Brubaker writing… dark, intense and engaging.  Actually, the writing seems so much like what we’ve seen from Brubaker in the past, it borders on the derivative.  Fortunately, it’s really good derivative stuff.  It may not be rare in the context of Brubaker’s comics CV.  And while there are other strong crime comics on the go right now, the genre’s not so prevalent that it doesn’t need another strong member among its ranks. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Marvel | Comments Off

Life Irritates Art

Posted by Don MacPherson on 19th September 2006

I don’t really need to review True Story, Swear to God v.2 #1. I’ve made my feelings about Tom Beland’s autobiographical, slice-of-life romance comic known time and time again.  I adore True Story, and I relate to much of what Beland explores in the book.  I’m thrilled that his self-published comic series is about to reach a wider audience with the release of a relaunch through Image Comics.  It’s bound to boost True Story‘s profile significantly, hopefully appealing to the cartooning fans of such other Image titles as Liberty Meadows and PvP.

So no, this is not a review of the new debut issue.  Instead, I want to explore a question that’s rather unique to this comic series: is True Story the same series that it was when it began?  And the truth is that no, it’s not the same book, but it has nothing to do with how Beland writes it now, how he illustrates it or how he markets it.

The change comes in the perspective of some of his readers, namely, those who are aware of the shift in Beland’s life today, as opposed to the past experiences that unfold in the comic.  Beland announced this year that he and wife Lily Garcia had split, albeit on amicable terms.  Developments in the creators’ personal lives are never a concern when it comes to one’s enjoyment of their comic-book storytelling, but in this case, it does have an effect.  You see, True Story is, among other things, a romance comic, and now, the readership knows the ending it was expecting for the autobio title will not come to pass. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Editorials | 17 Comments »

History Lessons

Posted by Don MacPherson on 19th September 2006

Island of Terror: Battle of Iwo Jima original graphic novella
Writer: Larry Hama
Artist: Anthony Williams
Cover artist: Gary Erskine
Publisher: Osprey Publishing
Price: $9.95 US/$13.95 CAN

This may strike some readers as shocking, even shameful, but my initial education on the Second World War stemmed from comics, specifically from Roy Thomas’s All-Star Squadron. As a result of my participation in a French immersion program throughout my grade-school years, my social studies courses were all presented in French. That meant a focus on Acadian and Quebecois history. World wars weren’t a big part of the curriculum. With this project and others, Osprey Publishing sets out to combine comics storytelling with history education, specifically when it comes to teaching younger readers about significant armed conflicts, key battles from world-changing wars. This graphic novella about the Battle of Iwo Jima is the fifth in the Osprey Graphic History series. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Miscellaneous | Comments Off