Daily Archives: September 30, 2006

Quick Critiques – Sept. 30, 2006

Amazing Spider-Man #535 (Marvel Comics)
by J. Michael Straczynski, Ron Garney & Bill Reinhold

In the wake of Marvel’s announced delay of numerous titles and the developments in Civil War #4, readers have loudly proclaimed how disappointed they are in the crossover event. I don’t blame them, and my voice chimed in with that chorus for certain verses. But there is value in the core premise that’s at the heart of Civil War, and select crossover tie-in issues show that.┬áThis is one of them. Straczynski handles the ethical and personal conflicts of the event far more convincingly here, so much so that I feel it’s a shame he didn’t have a more direct hand in the core crossover title itself. The new conflict between Spidey and Iron Man works incredibly well, and the scene between Peter and Reed makes the latter’s participation in the registration movement a bit easier to accept. Garney’s incorporates an energetic, traditional super-hero genre look with a slightly edgy, tense atmosphere that’s in keeping with the script. There’s nothing wrong with these ideas; it’s in the execution that they succeed or fall apart. 8/10

Continue reading… →