Eye on Comics

Comics criticism and commentary from Don MacPherson

Archive for August, 2007

The Book of Revelation (or Lack Thereof)

Posted by Don MacPherson on 29th August 2007

52 Aftermath: The Four Horsemen #1
“Resurrection”
Writer: Keith Giffen
Pencils: Pat Olliffe
Inks: John Stanisci
Colors: Hi-Fi
Letters: Pat Brosseau
Cover artist: Ethan Van Sciver
Editor: Michael Siglain
Publisher: DC Comics
Price: $2.99 US/$3.65 CAN

I really didn’t care all that much for the pseudo-nouveau Fourth World villains from 52, the Four Horsemen. Visually, the characters were a mess, and I felt they were built up so much that their quick demise made for an anti-climactic moment. Still, I’ve been a fan of Keith Giffen’s recent writing for Marvel (such as Drax the Destroyer and Annihilation: Conquest – Star-Lord), and I don’t think Pat Olliffe’s art has ever disappointed me. So I figured I’d give The Four Horsemen a chance. There’s some potential in the premise as it’s presented here, but ultimately, it’s hindered by an inaccessible script and what seems like a missed opportunity when it comes to marketing the book. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - DC | 4 Comments »

Flea Market Finds: X-Men #121

Posted by Don MacPherson on 28th August 2007

Last week, the leaders of the three North American nations gathered in Montebello, Quebec to negotiate, prevaricate and masticate some fine food. It wasn’t big news in the United States, judging from the 24-hour news networks, but in these parts, it was a significant event (if only for the security scandal that arose, with undercover officers acting as protesters). As luck would have it, I happened upon a comic book from the late 1970s that featured an American-Canadian summit of a different sort: an X-Men/Alpha Flight free-for-all.

It wasn’t a flea-market find, per se. My local comic shop had a big sale a few days ago, unloading all of the comics in its back-issue bins for a buck. As I usually do when I luck upon such a bargain blowout, I seek out 1970s and ’80s comics. I selected a few interesting items, such as a Marvel Two-in-One Annual, an alcoholism-era Iron Man and a Two-Face spotlight in Batman. As I got toward the end of the line of boxes, I reached the Xs. X-Men comics usually don’t hold a lot of interest for me, but I noticed there were some Chris Claremont/John Byrne issues of X-Men among the back issues.

“Cal, the high-end back issues are exempt from the sale, right?” “Anything in those boxes — one dollar.” I have so few of these classic X-Men comics in my collection; I wasn’t going to pass up the opportunity. I don’t care about the resale value; I’m not looking for eBay fodder. This was just a great opportunity to absorb some of the most fondly remembered super-hero storytelling of the era. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Features | 10 Comments »

Quick Critiques – Aug. 22, 2007

Posted by Don MacPherson on 22nd August 2007

Birds of Prey #109 (DC Comics)
by Tony Bedard, Nicola Scott & Doug Hazlewood

The post-Gail Simone era for Birds of Prey begins, and writer Tony Bedard demonstrates he has a strong grip on the characters. The cover proclaims the central plotline to be Barbara and Dinah’s discussion of the latter’s possible nuptials, and while it’s nice to see such a conversational, slice-of-life notion at the forefront of a super-hero book, it really doesn’t ring true. Generally, people don’t flat out tell their friends that the loves of their lives are pigs. They may think it, but they don’t say it. Unfortunately, the real point of this issue seems to be addressing continuity points. Through Oracle, Bedard addresses the ugly history of the Black Canary/Green Arrow relationship, but only those up on those past stories will really appreciate the transgressions being discussed. Furthermore, Bedard deals with the apparent dissolution of Simone’s Secret Six (I assume, thanks to Deadshot’s renewed involvement with the Suicide Squad, as seen in Countdown). On top of that, the storyline that really drives this issue forward is the ongoing “Death of the New Gods” concept, launched in Countdown as well. With Knockout and Big Barda associated with this title, I suppose Birds of Prey was a logical venue for a tie-in, but it just doesn’t fit with the espionage riff that’s part and parcel of this property. Inexplicably, there’s no overt cue that this is a Countdown crossover issue or that it would be of interest to fans of the late Jack Kirby’s Fourth World characters. Nicola Scott’s art is straightforward; she’s offers standard super-hero visuals here. But the storytelling is solid, and she manages to convey the strength of the more experienced heroines and the innocence of the younger characters. 5/10  Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Quick Critiques | 1 Comment »

Super-Team Family

Posted by Don MacPherson on 21st August 2007

The Flash #231
“The Wild Wests, Part One: Growing Up Fast”
Writer: Mark Waid
Artist: Daniel Acuna
Letters: Pat Brosseau
Cover artists: Acuna/Doug Braithwaite
Editor: Joan Hilty
Publisher: DC Comics
Price: $2.99 US/$3.65 CAN

Mark Waid’s return to this title and to the protagonist he molded into a fan favorite in the 1990s thankfully doesn’t result in a return to the same kinds of stories he told before with the help of such artists as Greg Laroque, Salvador Larroca, Paul Pelletier and the late, great Mike Wieringo. No, he’s opted to explore a completely different kind of dynamic with this turning point in the character’s four-color life. When Wally West took over the mantle of the Flash at first in the 1980s, the storytelling in this title revolved around him learning to be a man, bridging the divide between adolescence and adulthood. With Waid’s previous run on the book, we can assume Wally is well into his 20s and he’s learning to be a good man. Now, we have Wally in his 30s, learning to be a father. It’s a natural progression for the character (and for the readership, I would imagine), consistent with previous canon while providing a fresh take, distinct from previous incarnations. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - DC | 6 Comments »

Settle Down

Posted by Don MacPherson on 20th August 2007

I read with some interest the details of the settlement agreement between Harlan Ellison and Fantagraphics Inc., bringing to an end the former’s defamation and “right-to-publicity” lawsuit against the publisher over two publications: The Comics Journal Library 6: The Writers and the forthcoming book Comics as Art: We Told You So. I’m not a lawyer; I defer to the assessments and judgments of legal matters to my barrister/solicitor girlfriend and law professor/scholar brother. However, I do spend some amount of time pouring over court documents in my capacity as a crime/courts reporter for a daily newspaper. It is from that perspective that I write the following about the Ellison/Fantagraphics settlement:

It’s weird.    Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Editorials | 11 Comments »

Quick Critiques – Aug. 16, 2007

Posted by Don MacPherson on 16th August 2007

Batman #667 (DC Comics)
by Grant Morrison & J.H. Williams III

My God, how I’ve missed J.H. Williams’s art. It’s been more than two years since his and Alan Moore’s Promethea came to an end, and we’ve seen far too little of his work since that time. His contribution to this new story arc makes it clear just what we’ve been missing. He captures a sullen mood incredibly well while still presenting some of the super-hero characters as dramatically intense and dynamic. Williams manages to blend a mature, dark and modern tone with the campy qualities inherent in characters whose roots are firmly planted in the Silver Age. Williams makes the notion of grown men in silly warrior costumes seem plausible and almost normal. Dave Stewart’s dark, textured colors are almost solely responsible for the palpable tension throughout the book. Grant Morrison employs a classic mystery/thriller premise and some kitschy, obscure characters from yesteryear and takes them in an unusual direction. The writer opts to present some of the characters are impressive and imposing and others as laughing stocks, pale imitations of the accomplished men they once were or once believed themselves to be. I remember reading about the Batmen of All Nations from DC’s Who’s Who profile series in the 1980s, and I’m surprised Morrison was able to make use of them in such a dark story. In addition to the creepy mood, there’s a B-movie feel to the story as well that makes it all the more intriguing and entertaining. Morrison’s work on Batman has finally lived up to the promise we’d all hoped for when he was announced as the title’s writer. 9/10 Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Quick Critiques | 6 Comments »

Mike Wieringo, 1963-2007

Posted by Don MacPherson on 14th August 2007

For me, it all started with The Flash #80 in late 1993.

I was never much of a Flash fan despite my love for DC’s super-hero comics ever since the late 1970s. I hadn’t been reading Mark Waid’s much-lauded run on the Scarlet Speedster’s title. If memory serves, it was Alan Davis’s cover artwork that drew my attention to the book, but it was Mike Wieringo’s vision of the fleet-footed hero within that held it. His original, lantern-jawed interpretation of the Flash may not have been consistent with the sleekness inherent in a speedster character, but it was striking and attractive. Wieringo brought a mythic, larger-than-life quality to the character that was tempered by the grounded characterization Waid provided. Wieringo also did an amazing job of capturing the speed and energy of the title character. Both he and Waid brought a renewed sense of wonder and traditional comics storytelling to bear in a series that still had plenty of appeal for readers looking for a little more depth from the genre as well. Wieringo wasn’t on the title for that long, not really, but he left a mark on it that’s undeniable. His short stint earned him a place among the most favored artists to handle the character, and it quickly established him as a star talent in the comics industry.

One of Wieringo’s biggest claims to fame was co-creating Bart Allen, AKA Impulse. It’s actually a bit disconcerting how soon after Bart’s life as a character came to an end in a two-dimensional world that his co-creator followed suit in the real world. Sure, by the time Bart’s number was up, he’d become the Flash after a few years as Kid Flash, but the character was never more interesting or loved than when he was Impulse. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Editorials | 7 Comments »

Drinking Games

Posted by Don MacPherson on 13th August 2007

The Naked Artist: Comic Book Legends
Writer: Bryan Talbot
Artist/Cover artist: Hunt Emerson
Publisher: Moonstone Books
Price: $11.95 US

One of my favorite memories from the Comic-Con International San Diego in 2003 was sitting on the balcony of the hotel room I shared with Randy Lander, drinking dirty rum, reminiscing and telling stories. I thought back on the times we worked for a couple of different website companies together, talked comics, talked about women and laughed about it all. That con also saw a couple of unusual incidents (mostly alcohol-related) that will no doubt serve as future balcony-conversation fodder. The Naked Artist is a collection of the kinds of stories that comics professionals tell one another and recall together, no doubt over fine food and drink. This prose collection of true stories and false but fabulous myths is made up of short essays and even shorter snippets of a few well-known but many unknown yarns about the trials, tribulations and terrors experienced by creators whose work comics fans adore. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Miscellaneous | 2 Comments »

I Oni Have Eyes for You

Posted by Don MacPherson on 8th August 2007

What follows is a few Quick Critiques, which aren’t uncommon for this site. The difference this time is that all of the comics reviewed in this entry are published by Oni Press.

Oni may not be a Goliath in the comics industry, but it’s demonstrated over the past decade that’s definitely a David. Continue reading for brief reviews of brand new Oni offerings and one from earlier this year… Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Oni Press, Reviews - Quick Critiques | 8 Comments »

Elementary, My Dear Watson

Posted by Don MacPherson on 7th August 2007

Glister #1
“Glister and the Haunted Teapot”
“Rock Scissors Paper” (Skeleton Key story)
Writer/Artist/Cover artist: Andi Watson
Editor: Jamie S. Rich
Publisher: Image Comics
Price: $5.99 US

Andi Watson is a versatile creator who knows how to reach a wide array of readers with a diverse lineup of book. I’ve been particularly fond of his adult, slice-of-life comics, such as Breakfast After Noon and Slow News Day. Glister is a different kind of comic, though, and not just in terms of its smaller format. Watson tackles an old-fashioned approach to children’s storytelling here, and it’s thoroughly charming. Though it’s labelled as a book for “all ages,” it’s really more geared toward the younger set. I was amused, though, and I actually got a kick reading it aloud, adopting different voices for the various characters. I don’t have kids, but I was practising for a far-off, hypothetical time when I will. Sadly, my attempt to sound like a young British girl failed; instead, my attempt at Glister Butterworth sounded like an old woman, perhaps one of the three crones from Macbeth. In any case, I had fun reading the first story, mainly from imagining the reactions of a younger reader. The book also served as my introduction to Watson’s Skeleton Key characters. Though it wasn’t as accessible as I might have liked, I definitely see the appeal of the property. Overall, this was a cute book, and it should appeal to fans of kids’ fantasy literature and comics such as Ted Naifeh’s Courtney Crumrin. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Image | 1 Comment »

Architectural Digesting

Posted by Don MacPherson on 6th August 2007

The Architect original graphic novella
Writer: Mike Baron
Artist/Cover artist: Andie Tong
Colors: Mike Kilgore
Letters: Scott Bieser
Publisher: Big Head Press
Price: $9.95 US

Mike Baron is an award-winning comics writer with whom newer readers might not be familiar, and to be honest, I don’t think I’ve read a lot of his work either. I’ve read precious little of The Badger, the character for which he is best known, and there hasn’t been that much Nexus material available in recent years either. I’ve probably most familiar with Baron as the first writer to take The Flash when the title was relaunched in the wake of Crisis on Infinite Earths in the late 1980s, featuring the Wally West incarnation of the character. With this small-press project, Baron clearly demonstrates that he’s comfortable as a writer outside the super-hero genre. The Architect is an entertaining horror story, and with it, Baron shows that he has a soft spot for the horror comics of yesteryear and cheesy but amusing horror flicks as well. The plot hinges on a lot of coincidences, but they work within the context of the supernatural elements of the plot. Where this project goes awry is with its visuals. British artist Andie Tong offers some solid work here, but his style strikes me as a poor match for the darker tone for which the story strives. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Indy/Small Press | Comments Off

Quick Critiques – Aug. 2, 2007

Posted by Don MacPherson on 2nd August 2007

The Chemist #1 (Image Comics)
by Jay Boose

Writer/artist Jay Boose takes the reader into the criminal underworld, employing an unusual protagonist as a guide. The hero of the story is Vance Laroche, a chemist who has become obscenely rich reverse-engineering drugs for the underworld. This slick scientist becomes a fugitive, running from his crooked employers. Boose’s story is full of action, and but the fast pace of the story is balanced nicely by the inventiveness, resourcefulness and intellect of the protagonist. Boose combines a 1940s noir sensibility with high-octane, high-tech elements of today, making for a riveting read. I loved the more cosmopolitan touch he brings to the piece with the change in settings from Boston to Montreal. The woman whom Vance rescues from certain death makes for a perfect counterpart to his in-control, always prepared attitude. Alexis’s tough but clueless personality manages to bring the story down to earth a bit. She’s not stupid, but she’s definitely in over her head; her carefree outlook keeps her from freaking out and allows her to just enjoy the ride. Boose’s artwork looks like a cross between the styles of Tony (Ex Machina) Harris and Jason (Body Bags) Pearson. While detailed and realistic, Boose uses colors to immerse the story in a dark mood that’s in keeping with the classic, nostalgic look of crime-genre stories that have come before it. Sin, style and sexuality blend perfectly here for a story that reminds me of the sort of thing one might get from an issue of Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips’s award-winning series, Criminal. 9/10 Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - Quick Critiques | 1 Comment »

Metallurgy

Posted by Don MacPherson on 1st August 2007

Metal Men #1
Writer/Artist/Cover artist: Duncan Rouleau
Colors: Moose Baumann
Letters: Pat Brosseau
Editor: Eddie Berganza
Publisher: DC Comics
Price: $2.99 US/$3.65 CAN

Duncan Rouleau twisted, surreal and fluid style is a perfect match for DC’s oddball, shapechanging robotic heroes, the Metal Men. Rouleau is mainly known to DC and Marvel super-hero readers as an artist alone, not a writer. He’s no rookie when it comes to plotting and scripting, though, as those who have read his graphic novel, The Nightmarist, can attest. Just as he boasts an unusual and unique approach in his art, his writing is unconventional in tone as well. That makes for a challenging read, though, and that holds true here. The plot incorporates magicks from the dark ages, theoretical physics about the building blocks of reality and shapeshifting super-heroics. It’s not easy to follow the storytelling here, but one can’t deny the fun that’s to be had. While Rouleau’s time-jumping plot has yet to fully reveal itself, there’s enough entertainment value here to keep me on board until things make a little more sense. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in Reviews - DC | 7 Comments »