Daily Archives: March 31, 2008

Underdogs and Overreactions

The comic-book industry was agog at the news last week of Jerry Siegel’s family’s success in its legal fight to regain some copyright control over Superman and some contents of the classic Action Comics #1. Others have commented at length about the decision and what it means for comics, so there’s really no need for me to repeat what’s been stated eloquently (or in the case of some message-board posters, rudely and ignorantly). Besides, the story is far from over. It’s highly doubtful that Time Warner would capitulate in a battle over such a lucrative cash cow from distant Krypton. An appeal is no doubt in the works, regardless of whether or not the appellants have a spandex-clad leg to stand on.

The Siegel ruling is certainly historic for the world of comics, and it may be an important precedent beyond our little corner of pop culture. While creators’ rights have been a topic of discussion for industry insiders and enthusiasts of our little medium for a couple of decades now at least, it’s a notion that’s perhaps never been more prominent in the collective consciousness of Western culture. It was only a few months ago that the Writers Guild of America strike came to end, and that job action impacted just about every household in North America. It wasn’t in any real way that matters, but the public became away of creator rights as a broader principle.

Continue reading… →