What He Does Isn’t Pretty
Posted by Don MacPherson on April 8th, 2009

Wolverine: Weapon X #1
“The Adamantium Men, Part 1 of 5″
Writer: Jason Aaron
Artist: Ron Garney
Colors: Jason Keith
Letters: Virtual Calligraphy
Cover artists: Ron Garney/Adam Kubert/Olivier Coipel/Alan Davis
Editor: John Barber
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Price: $3.99 US
I didn’t enjoy this comic book at all, but honestly, I can’t blame the writer, the artist, the editor or the publisher. It’s my fault, you see. For some reason, I expected to find something a little different, something a little new. I’d heard good things about Jason Aaron’s Marvel work, and since I’ve enjoyed Ron Garney’s efforts in the past, I figured this newly launched series might something I’d appreciate. But hey, it’s a new Wolverine comic subtitled Weapon X. I’m at a loss to explain why I’d expect anything more than the typical blood, bravado and black ops that have been part and parcel of the title character for the past couple of decades.

People — innocent and otherwise — are being slaughtered in the jungles and villages of Colombia, decimated an elite squad of assassins, some of which seem to have some familiar edged weapons at their disposal. Meanwhile, back in San Francisco, Logan catches up with an old friend (but not before he comes to the aid of a damsel in distress, of course). Logan learns someone is putting the science and resources of the defunct Weapon X project to use, and he sets out to find out who’s behind it and what they’re doing with the deadly technology and philosophy.
Garney’s loose, sketchy but animated style suits the dark world of solo Wolverine stories quite well. It’s in keeping with the gritty qualities of the plot and the rough-around-the-edges look and attitude of the title character. He also conveys the arid, raw landscape of a South American village as easily as he takes us into the sleek and shiny labs of a government black-ops research facility. Still, there are times when the art looks a little generic. The colors serve the story well, and I like how Jason Keith employs an eerie, sci-fi green to convey the power of the unseen antagonists. The reader doesn’t know what the green glow is about, but s/he wants to find out.
So, for your $3.99 US, you get: 21 pages of story and art, along with a few filler pages and a preview of another Jason Aaron comic. DC Comics has adopted a number of $3.99 titles as well, but invariably, there’s value added along with the increase in cover price. Here, we have Marvel Comics getting its readership to pay for its advertising. “Thanks for paying too much for this comic book. In return, we offer you a plea to buy another one of our comics.” Also included is background information, a la Marvel Universe Handbook style, on the Weapon X project and one of the supporting characters who turns up in this issue. One might welcome this extra information, but Aaron’s script provides enough exposition about both elements on its own and in a much more concise fashion.
Wolverine’s bloody approach to justice works in the dark corners of the Marvel Universe where assassins hide or where super-villains lay waste to landscape and lives. But in an everyday urban environment — such as the train where part of this story takes place — his claws and willingness to kill and maim come off as far too harsh. For a moment, Wolverine stands out as the villain, as the criminal. The Punisher is a wanted man for this kind of behavior, so I wonder why Wolverine gets a free pass. I don’t care for him in that moment, not one bit. Now the new reporter character that’s introduced here is interesting at first, but there’s a stereotypical quality to her as well. Aaron obviously doesn’t get much of a chance to develop her character in this single issue, though, so it’s not as though I could expect to find any great depth at this point.
The creators deliver exactly what was asked of them and have earned their paycheques. All you need to know about this comic book is to be found in its title. It’s a typical Wolverine comic, and it’s connected to his past with the Weapon X program. End of story. If those elements appeals to you, you’ve probably already bought and enjoyed the issue. If they don’t, you probably avoided this comic in the first place. As I should have. It’s not a slight to the people who crafted this comic. I looked to this comic book to find something new, ignoring all the signs that there was nothing new to be found. 4/10
Advertise on Eye on Comics
April 9th, 2009 at 12:40 pm
Don wrote:
“Wolverine’s bloody approach to justice works in the dark corners of the Marvel Universe where assassins hide or where super-villains lay waste to landscape and lives. But in an everyday urban environment — such as the train where part of this story takes place — his claws and willingness to kill and maim come off as far too harsh. For a moment, Wolverine stands out as the villain, as the criminal.”
That’s exactly what I was thinking while reading that scene. Why doesn’t Aaron depict Wolverine of being capable of disarming a common thug without the use of his claws? There’s a scene from Claremont and Byrne’s run on Uncanny where Storm as newly-appointed field leader reprimands Logan for the willingness to use his claws during battle. She explains that due to his adamantium-laced bones and healing factor he is more than capable of dealing with enemies without having to resort to lethal force. I think this is an approach that should be adopted by the writers of Wolverine comics in the future. Wolverine as unbeatable killing machine has become so so boring.
April 9th, 2009 at 5:21 pm
Don wrote:
“I looked to this comic book to find something new, ignoring all the signs that there was nothing new to be found”.
Right now this is happening with the 99% of the comics of DC and Marvel. Nothing is new and — between you and me – this is the curse of the super-hero genre. You see i like super-hero (toilet) comics. I have thousands but one morning i wake up and discovered that this thing will never end. These guys just don’t die. Never. Recycle is the magic word.
Let me ask you a question? How many Wolverine comics you have read in your life. You don’t remember? Neither do I. I dont care. Some where good, some where bad. I buy Wolverine every month because i’m addict. Its my heroin and I want to quit. I want to put all Wolverine comics in a box, hide it for 10 years. Then i want to re-read all this stories. Because i want to remember something. And if you’re buying 50 or 60 comics per month you end up forgetting them all.
When i was a 10 years old (now i am 34) i was buying the classic Spider-Man stories. The greek publisher put them in black and white. I had to wait one Week to read 64 pages filled with super-heroes. Now i can read numerous titles but the fun has been lost. You see you cant read them all. You have to choose and this is bad.
Right now I prefer to read Scalped (this is the real Jason Aaron), everything from Tezuka, Urasawa or the trades of Rex Mundi, or Ex Machina, or the new Starman hardcovers (even Jack Kirby’s New Gods), or Vagabond, or re-read Transmetropolitan, or complete Tom Strong, or DMZ, or Walking Dead (they put it greek!), or Bone, or Usagi Yojimbo, or Berlin, or Allred’s X-Force, or Camelot 3000, or From Hell, or Storm (one of the greatest sci-fi comics of all time drawn by the amazing british artist Don Lawrence), or everything from Hernadez brothers, or Rex Libris or… Like super-hero comics the list never ends. Ok I keep Batman and Daredevil for the toilet…
April 11th, 2009 at 3:16 pm
The horrible mistake — and it really is something comic companies should have noticed by now — made in this comic is that the cliffhanger revelation is… the hook we were told to get us to buy the comic in the first place!
Seriously: what have we learned in this comic other than “Roxxon’s making new Weapons”? And what does it say in Previews?